Jump to Navigation

Salt Lake City Criminal Law Blog

What Juror Confusion Over Terms Can Mean in a Murder Case

When a jury considers guilt in a criminal case, it also is asked to consider the intent of the person who committed the crime. Did the person intend to do wrong or cause harm or was the result accidental? The question of intent is significant when it comes to sentencing, especially in criminal cases involving violent crimes like murder.

The courts punish purposeful crimes more severely than negligent crimes. The difference between first-degree murder (purposeful homicide) and manslaughter (reckless or negligent homicide) can be many years added to a prison sentence.

Can a Person Be Convicted for Illegal Drug Possession in Utah for Simply Being Near Illegal Drugs?

We often get asked if a person can be convicted for drug possession if they were merely near the illegal drugs that were found. For example, let's assume three friends are in a car, Joe, Cindy and Parker. They get pulled over for "swerving". The officer claims he smells marijuana (because of his superbionic nose), and so he searches the car. Under the passenger seat, he finds some marijuana. Joe was driving, Cindy was in the front passenger seat, and Parker was asleep in the back seat.

One person recently said this me: "Hey, I understand I am guilty no matter what, right? After all, we are in Utah!"

However, there is much more to it than that, and the Utah Supreme Court has made it clear that simply being near illegal drugs when they are found is NOT enough to support of conviction of guilt.

Horizontal and Vertical Gaze Nystagmus Test (The "EYE TEST")

There are several types of field sobriety tests (FSTs) used by law enforcement officers while investigating DUI in Utah. Being arrested for DUI can be a very unnerving experience. If you are charged with DUI in Utah, be sure to hire an experienced Utah DUI lawyer who will fight to protect your rights. The attorneys at Greg Smith and Associates are seasoned Utah criminal defense lawyers who will work to obtain the best possible resolution of your case.

One of the most commonly used FSTs is the Horizontal and Vertical Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) test. Nystagmus is involuntary jerking of the eyes. Utah Prosecution Council, Driving Under the Influence Prosecution Manual (2007), http://www. sentencing.utah.gov/ProsecutionManual/chapter8.pdf.

Do field sobriety tests (FSTs) violate a person's Fifth Amendment right against compelled self-incrimination?

In a previous posting, I wrote about the definition, history and accuracy of field sobriety tests. Now, I would like to discuss the implications of FSTs on your constitutional rights. Remember, if you are ever charged with a DUI or other crime in Utah, it is important that you hire an effective Utah defense attorney to protect your rights such as one from Greg Smith and Associates. With over 20 years of criminal defense experience in Utah, we have the experience and knowledge to aggressively fight for you.

Does the Fifth Amendment apply to FSTs? No, you cannot invoke your Fifth Amendment right against compelled self-incrimination if asked to perform FSTs by a law enforcement officer. Utah Prosecution Council, Driving Under the Influence Prosecution Manual (2007), http://www.sentencing.utah.gov/ProsecutionManual/chapter8.pdf.

Implied Consent

Assume you are pulled over by a cop, and you are stone cold SOBER. The cop asks you to take a breath test. You feel he is just trying to hassle you. You are outraged, so you refuse. The sad part about this is you could lose your license for 18 months for that refusal.

Most states have some form of an implied consent law on the books. If you are ever pulled over and suspected of DUI, you should know the law so you can best protect your rights. If you are charged with DUI it's also important that you get an excellent, affordable DUI lawyer such as one from Greg Smith and Associates.

So, what is implied consent? In Utah, the implied consent law states that "[a] person operating a motor vehicle in this state is considered to have given the person's consent to a chemical test or tests of the person's breath, blood, urine, or oral fluids for the purposes of determining whether the person was operating" a vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs. (Utah Code Annotated 41-6a-520).

What Are Field Sobriety Tests?

If you have ever been suspected of driving under the influence (DUI) in Utah, then you have probably had to perform Standardized Field Sobriety Tests (FSTs). If not, then it is likely that you have seen others performing FSTs on the side of the road. Remember, if you are facing charges for DUI in Utah it is important that you get an effective and affordable DUI lawyer to represent you and protect your rights.

What are FSTs? A typical DUI investigation in Utah involves FSTs and a chemical test. In an earlier blog I talked about Implied Consent and chemical tests (blood, breath, urine and saliva samples). According to the Utah Prosecution Council's Driving Under the Influence Prosecution Manual, FSTs "are the tools to aid officers in determining whether a person is impaired by the consumption of alcohol or drugs." (§ 8.1)

Question: How severe can a penalty really be for simply failing to pay child support in the state of Utah?

Short answer: As the case below shows (United States v. Mitrano, First Circuit), you can actually be sent to a federal prison for years. So, if you are past due on your child support obligation in Utah, please call Greg Smith and Associates immediately (801-651-1512). They are highly skilled in the areas of child support law and criminal law.

Sometimes even a very "well educated person" can simply outsmart himself when it comes to criminal law matters. For example, just because a person is a lawyer that does not mean they are qualified to step into all legal areas as Mr. Mitrano had to learn the hard way.

What If I Get Behind on My Child Support Obligation?

By Greg Smith and Brett Skidmore

Most people may be aware of the fact that stiff penalties await those who fail to stay current on their child support obligations in the state of Utah, such as wage garnishments and/or driver's license suspension. However, few may realize that even more serious consequences can result from the failure to remain in compliance with a child support order.

According to the Utah Criminal Code section 76-7-201, a person may be charged with "criminal nonsupport" if he or she "knowingly fails to provide for the support of . . . [a] child, or children when any one of them: a) is in needy circumstances; or b) would be in needy circumstances but for support received from a source other than the defendant's behalf."

Section 76 provides that criminal nonsupport is a class A misdemeanor - which is not something to be taken lightly. However, an individual may be charged with a 3rd degree felony if he or she "has been convicted one or more times of nonsupport, whether in this state, or any other state, or any court of the United states; committed the offense while residing outside of Utah; or commits the crime of nonsupport in each of 18 individual months within any 24-month period, or the total arrearage is in excess of $10,000."

The Cops and the Prosecutor Can't Prove the Drugs Were Mine!

We often hear our clients say, "The cops and the prosecutor can't prove the drugs were mine!" And many times they are 100% right, and the case will either get dismissed entirely, reduced, or the jury will find them to be not guilty.

After all, simply being near illegal drugs such as marijuana, meth, cocaine, ecstasy, heroine, etc. in Utah is not a crime. However, there is much more to it than that, and sometimes a person will get convicted for just being at the wrong place at the wrong time.

And Prosecutors can be all over the board in Utah when it comes to how they view such allegations of illegal drug possession and/or intent to distribute. For example, a prosecutor in Salt Lake may not handle the case the way a prosecutor from Ogden, Provo, Moab, Vernal, St. George, or Logan may. If the case gets turned over the feds, the matter instantly becomes a whole lot worse. That is why it is essential to hire an experienced defense team, which is very family with these types of illegal drug possession allegations, and how to properly defend against them such as Greg Smith and Associates, a criminal defense firm.

Interstate I-80 in Utah

We often get asked this question: Can the police in Utah pull a person over just because the passengers are young, have out of state plates, or because they are driving on I-80 near Wendover, Tooele, Salt Lake City or Park City, Utah? (Of course, we also hear this about Moab, Vernal, St. George, Cedar City, etc.)

And if the police then find marijuana or drugs with a drug-sniffing dog, can the defendant get the evidence thrown out of court?

Here is the long answer. Many people that drive on Interstate 80 near Wendover, Tooele, Salt Lake City or Park City, Utah do get pulled over for minor traffic offenses. Many just get written a ticket, then get let go. But, others have their cars searched. And many of our clients feel those searches are totally bogus. This happens to many campers at Utah campgrounds, too. Rule of thumb: while in Utah, never possess marijuana or any other illegal drug because there is a good chance you may get searched, especially if you are on a Utah interstate like I-80.



Clients with disabilities or impairments
Access to our office is available to clients and their family members at all times. Special equipment and communication devices are available upon request for our clients with visual, hearing, speech and physical impairment. In addition, arrangements can be made for verbal or sign language interpreters if needed to communicate between our attorneys and the client and family. Please notify our law office if any additional accommodations related to your disability or impairment are necessary to make your consultation more comfortable.

Feedback from satisfied clients
  • "The domestic violence and DUI crimes that I was charged with would have ruined my career. Thank you for saving me! You are worth every penny I paid you."
  • "I love the fact that you would meet with me on weeknights and weekends. Nobody else I talked to would do that for me."
  • "I thought I was a dead duck when I was charged with my crimes. You guys are miracle workers. I've referred many of my friends to you."
  • "We have had to hire lawyers in the past, but none of them was as easy to get on the phone, and your fees were more than fair. You have a client for life!"
more testimonials

Greg Smith & Associates
2150 South 1300 East, Suite 500 :: Salt Lake City UT 84106
:: Telephone: 801-924-4934 ::
Telephone: 888-708-8867 :: Salt Lake City Law Office :: E-mail the firm

Greg Smith & Associates
8813 C-2 South Redwood Road :: West Jordan UT 84088 :: Telephone: 801-924-4934 ::
Telephone: 888-708-8867 :: Fax: 801-255-2134
:: West Jordan Law Office :: E-mail the firm

Greg Smith & Associates
1526 Ute Boulevard Suite 209 :: Park City UT 84068
:: Telephone: 801-651-1512 ::
Telephone: 888-708-8867
:: Park City Law Office :: E-mail the firm

Greg Smith & Associates
2510 Washington Boulevard, Suite 200 :: Ogden UT 84401
::
Telephone: 888-708-8867 :: Ogden Law Office :: E-mail the firm

Greg Smith and Associates | Criminal Law Attorneys

Privacy Policy | FirmSite® by FindLaw, a Thomson Reuters business.